I've got a hint for you. Reasonable discussion doesn't kick off with sudden authoritarian declarations.

You've got a village full of people who have been imprisoned -- some of us for years -- and the last thing we need is someone taking away even more of our self-determination and autonomy.

And don't think I didn't miss that bit about not using the information against our captors. Why are you surprised that people are pissed off, when you've basically declared that you're siding with them against us?